Quality of raw cow milk produced by artisanal methods in rural localities in the Savannah Region in Togo
Abel Essowedeou Abli, Tiatou Souho, Damipie Bomboma, Marcelle Essoyodou Kabassina, Geraud Hellow, Alexandra Badabo, Nicole Boukari, Sabiba Kou´santa Amouzou
Corresponding author: Tiatou Souho, Laboratoire des Sciences Agronomiques et Biologiques Appliquées, Université de Kara, Kara, Togo 
Received: 02 Feb 2026 - Accepted: 16 Sep 2026 - Published: 19 Oct 2026
Domain: Sanitation,Food safety
Keywords: Cow milk, sanitary quality, bacterial contaminants, fungal contaminants
Funding: This work received no specific grant from any funding agency in the public, commercial, or non-profit sectors.
©Abel Essowedeou Abli et al. PAMJ-One Health (ISSN: 2707-2800). This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution International 4.0 License (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
Cite this article: Abel Essowedeou Abli et al. Quality of raw cow milk produced by artisanal methods in rural localities in the Savannah Region in Togo. PAMJ-One Health. 2026;21:10. [doi: 10.11604/pamj-oh.2026.21.10.51414]
Available online at: https://www.one-health.panafrican-med-journal.com/content/article/21/10/full
Research 
Quality of raw cow milk produced by artisanal methods in rural localities in the Savannah Region in Togo
Quality of raw cow milk produced by artisanal methods in rural localities in the Savannah Region in Togo
Abel Essowedeou Abli1,
Tiatou Souho1,&, Damipie Bomboma1, Marcelle Essoyodou Kabassina1, Geraud Hellow2, Alexandra Badabo2, Nicole Boukari2, Sabiba Kou'santa Amouzou1
&Corresponding author
Introduction: cow milk is used either as a key food or as an ingredient in the preparation of some meals. Its production is therefore an important element in the achievement of food and nutritional security. Given its composition as a stable emulsion containing both macronutrients and micronutrients, it is a medium subjected to a wide range of contaminations, making it a specific food that can be a gateway for microbial infections. The present study was designed to evaluate microbial contaminants in locally produced raw milk in a Togolese Savannah Region which is marked by milk production as a key economic activity practiced by women.
Methods: milk producers were identified based on a list of producers that was initially realized during a previous implementation program. The study was a systematic investigation of practices and milk quality of these producers. The quality of milk was investigated in the laboratory after milk samples collection by performing total mesophilic aerobic flora count, count of Staphylococcus aureus, and Salmonella spp, and quantification of yeast and mold.
Results: collected data show that the total mesophilic aerobic flora is above the standard for 95% of the samples. Staphylococcus aureus was identified in numbers above the standard for 88% of samples, but Salmonella was observed in 45% of samples.
Conclusion: these results show that milk production in this region should be more monitored and producers should be subjected to training regarding good practices to reduce milk contamination and produce acceptable milk regarding microbiological quality.
Milk is one of the most essential foods for human beings. As for other mammals, milk constitutes the first and best food for newborns for months, but it is still present in the list of meals consumed even in adulthood for humans [1]. It is a perfect source of several nutrients, including macronutrients and micronutrients [2]. The milk is at the center of nutritional recommendations for children and adolescents, especially in regions where malnutrition is highly prevalent [3,4]. It is therefore a determinant element that has to be available and accessible for the achievement of food security. Its production implies several factors that shape patterns of food production and consumption in the world, even if the current trend is a dynamic toward less consumption of animal-source foods [5].
Despite its evidenced added value in attaining food security, the milk value chain is among the less exploited ones in sub-Saharan countries. In Togo, milk production is still artisanal and realized by women. Data on the rates of milk production in the country are rare, but estimates tend to show that local production is below demand [6]. In addition, this production depends on the climate and its instability due to climate change, which seriously affects the region of livestock production. The region with the greatest number of cows is the northern country, which is marked by relatively high temperatures and reduced lengths of raining seasons. This characteristic is well exploited by grain producers for conservation [7]. However, for milk production, this temperature exposes the milk to the risk of contaminant microbes' proliferation if there is deficiencies in hygiene practices [8]. It is therefore necessary to empower women involved in milking, milk transformation, and selling regarding hygiene practices and ways to minimize microbial contamination.
The present study was designed with the purpose of establishing baseline data on the sanitary quality of milk sold in the Togolese region with the highest level of milk production. More specifically, the study intended to evaluate the milk production process as well as microbial contamination markers in the produced milk.
Studied region and period: the study was performed in the Savannah Region in Togo, where cattle farming is practiced with the highest number of cows. Milk producers from the following localities were investigated: Koumongou, Sagbiebou, Mogou, Tchanaga, and Borgou (Figure 1). These localities were initially identified by browsing data on milk production collected by Veterinaire Sans Frontieres Suisse in Togo during the WOMEN project (Wagashi sain pour une optimisation des revenus des Ménages Exploitant le lait local au Nord du Togo). The project's purpose was to improve the resilience of vulnerable households depending on milk and dairy food production in the Savannah Region. The five localities were the ones with the highest number of milk-producing households. These localities were all rural, where economic activities revolve around agriculture and livestock, with milking performed mainly by women, cattle farmers' wives, and female family members. The study was performed in the period between November 2023 and February 2024.
Assessment of the milking practice: women involved in milk production were contacted a few days before the arrival of the research team, and focus groups were organized. In focus groups, producers were asked to describe their milking process, the practice of hygienic rules, and their methods of milk conditioning. One focus group was conducted in each locality.
Milk sampling: at the end of focus groups, milk samples, already conditioned for selling, were taken in sterile bottles, stored temporarily in coolers, and transported, as quickly as possible, to the laboratory for analyses. The number of samples was set to be at least 10 for each locality. Analyses performed in the laboratory include total plate count of mesophilic flora, Staphylococcus species count, detection of Salmonella, and count of yeast and mold.
Microbial analyses: the total mesophilic flora count was performed using a standard method. Milk samples underwent serial decimal dilutions, and each dilution tube was used as an inoculum (100 μL) on plate count agar petri dishes. Inoculums were then spread on the plates' agar surfaces and incubated at 30°C for 48 h.
Staphylococcus aureus contaminants were quantified using the Baird-Parker agar medium method. Successive decimal dilutions of samples were spread on Baird-Parker agar petri dishes. The petri dishes were incubated at 37°C for 48 h. Characteristic convex colonies were counted after incubation [9].
The presence of pathogenic Enterobacteriaceae was determined by the detection of Salmonella spp in the samples using the Salmonella-Shigella agar method. Samples were subjected to a pre-enrichment in peptone water for 24 h. The pre-enriched samples were then diluted in decimal series and each dilution was used as inoculum of 100 μL spread on the surface of Salmonella-Shigella agar petri dishes. Petri dishes were incubated at 37°C for 48h and characteristic colonies were detected [10].
Yeast and mold count was performed on Sabouraud Chloramphenicol after an incubation at 30°C for 72h. Milk samples were serially diluted without enrichment. An inoculum of 100μL of each dilution was spread on the Sabouraud Chloramphenicol agar medium and colonies were counted at the end of incubation [11].
Statistical analyses: laboratory tests were performed in triplicate. All data were computed using Microsoft Excel software and statistical analyses were performed using IBM SPSS v 20 software. Statistical tests were performed accordingly with a statistical significance set at p < 0.05.
Milk production process, hygiene and conditioning: focus groups interestingly revealed that all women produce their milk using the same process. They milk cows manually and filter it using artisanal filters such as baskets made of oil palm leaves or filters made of synthetic fiber acquired in the local market.
After filtration, the produced milk is directly introduced into plastic bottles of different sizes. These bottles are, in fact, used water or other drink bottles that are obtained either from markets or retrieved from previous clients. Bottles containing the produced milk are disposed of alongside the roads where consumers can buy it.
Regarding the practice of hygiene, all producers declared that they wash their hands before milking, filtration, and conditioning. The milk containers and all used tools such as filters undergo detergent washing before their use. They also declared that all bottles are cleaned with water and detergents before pouring in the milk to be sold. However, the obtained milk after bottling does not undergo specific treatments.
Milk samples: a total of 75 milk samples were obtained; the collected samples were 11 in Koumongou; 14 in Sagbiebou; 8 in Tchanaga; 28 in Mogou, and 14 in Borgou. The expected number of samples was not obtained in Tchanaga because producers reported that the sampling period is not appropriate for optimal milk production.
Total mesophilic flora of sampled milk: all collected samples were subjected to microbial analyses. The test of total mesophilic flora counts revealed values ranging from 7.1 x 104 to 109 cfu/mL (Table 1). As depicted in Table 1, only four (5.33%) samples presented counts below the standard of 105 cfu/mL [12]. Among the four samples, 3 were samples from Sagbiebou and the fourth was a sample collected from Mogou.
Pathogenic bacteria in the collected samples: regarding the pathogenic flora, Staphylococcus aureus was observed in nine (12%) samples with counts above 100 cfu/mL. The nine samples with high levels of Staphylococcus aureus were from Koumongou (33.33%), Borgou (33.33%), Tchanaga (22.22%), and Mogou (11.11%).
Salmonella spp were detected in 41 (54.67%). All these samples were from Koumongou and Sagbiebou (Table 1). The remaining 34 samples did not give rise to salmonella specific bacterial growth after inoculation in Salmonella-Shigella agar media.
Fungi in milk samples: fungi count was performed without further distinction between yeast and mold. They were observed in 45 (60%) samples with fungal growth exceeding the standard of 104 cfu/mL. The samples without fungal contaminants were from Koumongou (7 samples), Sagbiebou (4 samples), Tchanaga (4 samples), and Mogou (15 samples). All samples from Borgou were contaminated with fungi (Table 1).
The present study is, to our knowledge, the first one to systematically investigate the practice of women who produce and sell raw cow milk in the Northern Region of Togo, where livestock is the most abundant in the country. Focus groups allowed us to realize that milking and selling cow milk is an old economic activity dedicated to women. Indeed, the practice across all the localities was found to be the same, showing that milking practices are somehow standardized in the society and transmitted through generations from one woman to her daughters [13]. This finding shows that interventions that could alter the “ancestral” process of milking could encounter resistance. Modernizing the milking process and its transformation process should take into consideration the fact that key steps should be kept unchanged in order to maintain women in the milk value chain [14]. The practice of hygienic measures seems insufficient. Women clean their hands, but the quality of the water used was not investigated. However, it is well known that the region suffers from a lack of clean and potable water, making them use water from wells, rivers, and drillings.
Results of mesophilic aerobic flora count show that the milk sold in the region by milk-producing women presents, in most cases, high levels of microbes. This shows that the general hygienic character of the milk samples is not good. The microbial germs, including bacteria and fungi, originate from the initial microbial flora and contamination from milking women and the material used. Given that the milk samples were not directly collected from the milking site, it makes sense to assume that the high temperature in the region is a factor that promoted microbial proliferation in the milk from milking to sampling. Similar results were also observed in Niger, a Sahelian country where milk production is similar to the process as well as the climate in the studied region [15]. It is important to note that the climatic constraint on the microbial quality is a factor that promotes livestock and milk production [16]. This fact confirms that warm temperatures can be valorized as a milk production-promoting factor but should be controlled in order to limit the proliferation of microbes that hinder the sanitary quality. In sum, improving milk sanitary quality must include training for appropriate hygiene practices but also equipment to allow milk conservation in cool temperatures.
When considering the presence of Staphylococcus aureus, a microbe that is mainly present on humans' skin as well as in animals' skin. Results show that more than 90% of collected samples contain these bacteria in levels above the limit. It is a confirmation of the insufficiency of hygienic precautions made during milking. When producers wash hands and nipples before milking, the presence of Staphylococcus aureus tends to indicate that they don't do it properly. Interventions should be made in order to provide more effective detergents, clean water, and good practices. More important is the necessity for simple and affordable systems for conditioned raw milk heating and subsequent maintenance in cooling conditions until acquisition by consumers [17].
Another important finding in the present study is the presence of pathogenic Salmonella in milk samples from all localities. There is therefore a serious problem of public health. There is a need for further studies of this pathogen in order to better understand the distribution and effects of this pathogen on livestock, milk producers' households, and milk consumers. Such studies require a one health approach to better cope with the situation [17,18].
The present study sheds light on a set of serious public health issues related to the hygienic practices of milk producers and livestock pathogens in the Northern Region of Togo. When considering the fact that the region is an important exchange point where transhuman cow breeders from Sahelian countries meet their pairs settled in Togo, the problem should be given special attention by authorities and all stakeholders involved in the milk value chain. Results from the study show the necessity for a continuous training program on accessible approaches to hygiene practices for women involved in raw milk production and selling. Veterinary surveillance of the region in a one health approach should also be performed in order to limit the emergence and propagation of pathogens. In addition, further studies of microbes in this milk could reveal some technologically valuable germs that could be used in milk transformation.
What is known about this topic
- The production of milk in the Savannah Region is impacted by climate change;
- Cow milk and dairy foods are produced and sold by women in the Savannah Region;
- Untreated milk is a medium particularly susceptible to microbial contamination and proliferation.
What this study adds
- The milking process is the same throughout the Savannah Region in Togo;
- Artisanal milk presents high levels of microbial contamination in the Savannah Region in Togo;
- Simple and locally adapted solutions are necessary to help producers improve the quality of artisanal milk.
The authors declare no competing interests.
Conceptualization: Tiatou Souho, Geraud Hellow, and Sabiba Kou'santa Amouzou; data curation: Abel Essowedeou Abli and Tiatou Souho; formal analysis: Abel Essowedeou Abli, Tiatou Souho, Damipie Bomboma, and Marcelle Essoyodou Kabassina; funding acquisition: Geraud Hellow, Alexandra Badabo, and Nicole Boukari; investigation: Abel Essowedeou Abli, Tiatou Souho, Damipie Bomboma, and Marcelle Essoyodou Kabassina; methodology: Abel Essowedeou Abli, Tiatou Souho, Damipie Bomboma, Marcelle Essoyodou Kabassina, and Sabiba Kou'santa Amouzou; project administration and supervision: Tiatou Souho and Sabiba Kou'santa Amouzou; resources: Tiatou Souho, Geraud Hellow, Alexandra Badabo, and Nicole Boukari; writing - original draft: Abel Essowedeou Abli and Tiatou Souho; writing - review and editing: Abel Essowedeou Abli, Tiatou Souho, Damipie Bomboma, Marcelle Essoyodou Kabassina, Geraud Hellow, Alexandra Badabo, Nicole Boukari, and Sabiba Kou'santa Amouzou. All the authors read and approved the final version of this manuscript.
Table 1: distribution of samples meeting standards
Figure 1: map of the studied region
- Kabassina ME, Souho T, Bomboma D, Aglago EK, Compaoré E, Abli AE et al. Practice of Exclusive Breastfeeding: A Narrative Review of Its Relevance and Added Value as a Public Health Strategy to Reduce the Double Burden of Malnutrition. Food and Nutrition Sciences. 2026 Apr 27;17(4):375-99. Google Scholar
- Kumar S, Kumari S, Kumar S, Lodh J, Aparna VP. Chapter 24 - Role of milk as a source of micronutrients for human health. InHandbook of Milk Production, Quality and Nutrition. Academic Press. 2025;283-295. Google Scholar
- Drewnowski A. Perspective: Milk and Dairy Provide Affordable High-Quality Protein and Merit Inclusion in the Protein Foods Group. Curr Dev Nutr. 2024 Dec 21;9(1):104539. PubMed | Google Scholar
- Mahfuz M, Alam MA, Das S, Fahim SM, Hossain MS, Petri WA Jr et al. Daily Supplementation With Egg, Cow Milk, and Multiple Micronutrients Increases Linear Growth of Young Children with Short Stature. J Nutr. 2020 Feb 1;150(2):394-403. PubMed | Google Scholar
- Henchion M, Moloney AP, Hyland J, Zimmermann J, McCarthy S. Review: Trends for meat, milk and egg consumption for the next decades and the role played by livestock systems in the global production of proteins. Animal. 2021 Dec;15 Suppl 1:100287. PubMed | Google Scholar
- Corniaux C, Duteurtre G. Étude relative à la formulation d’un programme régional de promotion des chaînes de valeur lait local au sein de la CEDEAO, de la Mauritanie et du Tchad. Rapport final. Étude réalisée par le CIRAD pour le compte du Hub Rural, Dakar, Sénégal. 2018.
- Souho T, Bomboma D, Compaoré EW, Essowèréou AA, Ouadja B, Kabassina M et al. Grains production in high climate change impacted regions and its potential for the supply of critical nutrients for humans nutritional well being. Food Production, Processing and Nutrition. 2023 Jul 2;5(1):31. Google Scholar
- Niyonzima E, Nishimwe K, Jackson-Davis A, Mugisha J, Mugabo D, Nkundizanye S et al. Milk Safety in Rwanda: Examining Practices, Microbial Contamination, and Antibiotic Residues Along the Milk Value Chain. J Food Prot. 2025 Dec 10;88(12):100641. PubMed | Google Scholar
- Gebremedhin EZ, Ararso AB, Borana BM, Kelbesa KA, Tadese ND, Marami LM et al. Isolation and Identification of Staphylococcus aureus from Milk and Milk Products, Associated Factors for Contamination, and Their Antibiogram in Holeta, Central Ethiopia. Vet Med Int. 2022 May 6;2022:6544705. PubMed | Google Scholar
- Papadopoulou C, Maipa V, Dimitriou D, Pappas C, Voutsinas L, Malatou H. Behavior of Salmonella enteritidis During the Manufacture, Ripening, and Storage of Feta Cheese Made from Unpasteurized Ewe's Milk. J Food Prot. 1993 Jan;56(1):25-28. PubMed | Google Scholar
- Mayoral MB, Martín R, Sanz A, Hernández PE, González I, García T. Detection of Kluyveromyces marxianus and other spoilage yeasts in yoghurt using a PCR-culture technique. Int J Food Microbiol. 2005 Nov 15;105(1):27-34. PubMed | Google Scholar
- International Organization for Standardization. Microbiology of food and animal feeding stuffs: Horizontal method for the enumeration of microorganisms: Colony-count technique at 30° C. 2003:1-9.
- Gelaw A, Abegaz S, Mohammed N, Ahmed M. Farmer's traditional practices in milk and milk products handling in selected districts of North Wollo, Ethiopia. Heliyon. 2024 Dec 3;10(23):e40866. PubMed | Google Scholar
- Amenu K, Agga GE, Kumbe A, Shibiru A, Desta H, Tiki W et al. MILK Symposium review: Community-tailored training to improve the knowledge, attitudes, and practices of women regarding hygienic milk production and handling in Borana pastoral area of southern Ethiopia. J Dairy Sci. 2020 Nov;103(11):9748-9757. PubMed | Google Scholar
- Gagara MH, Sessou P, Dossa FSP, Azokpota P, Youssao IAK, Gouro SA et al. Hygienic quality of raw and fermented cow milk in the local milk sector of the Liptako-Gourma area in Niger. Vet World. 2022 Jun;15(6):1541-1549. PubMed | Google Scholar
- Rashid M, Aboshady HM, Agamy R, Archimede H. Milk production and composition in warm-climate regions: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Trop Anim Health Prod. 2024 Nov 14;56(8):382. PubMed | Google Scholar
- Mariama G, Philippe S, Serge A, Paulin A, Issaka Y, Souaà F et al. Analyses of constraints related to milk production in Liptako Gourma in Niger. African Journal of Agricultural Research. 2017 Jun 8;12(23):1949-58. Google Scholar
- Silva C, Calva E, Maloy S. One Health and Food-Borne Disease: Salmonella Transmission between Humans, Animals, and Plants. Microbiol Spectr. 2014 Feb;2(1):OH-0020-2013. PubMed | Google Scholar



